(Source: http://all-funny.info/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Indian-Chief.jpg)
As
a boy, I remember going to southern Utah to hunt for Native American pottery
and arrowheads with my grandparents. They would tell me captivating tales about
the once-great Native American tribes, using the artifacts we found as proof of
their existence. For the modern-day Native American, I observe a single story told
by the media: Native Americans are lazy alcoholics who are stuck in the past and
live off government handouts. This stereotype is clearly presented in the
following artifacts.
This graph illustrates that Native Americans are supposedly
#1 when it comes to alcohol abuse by race/ethnicity in the United States. Such
reporting by NBC News, a reputable source for information, further supports the
single story about Native Americans that claims they are alcoholics.
This cartoon shows a white male shaking his head as he sees
what has become of the “Vanishing American.” The image presented here seeks to
prove that Native Americans lazily spend their days in meaningless businesses.
Both smoke shops and casinos are places that suggest idling away time and
wasting money and resources. Additionally, Native American casinos have been
portrayed in a similarly mocking light by TV series such as Family Guy and
South Park.
The above comic depicts a downtrodden Native American with a
failing casino who is assured by his business partner that the U.S. government
will take care of them with government handouts. Like images and the sheer
amount of Native American scholarship funds (see https://www.scholarships.com/financial-aid/college-scholarships/scholarships-by-type/minority-scholarships/american-indian-native-american-scholarships/)
both contribute to the stereotype that Native Americans find it difficult to
survive in the modern world and require government aid.
I think that the messages being sent about modern Native
Americans matter and should be given attention. They not only show what the
media perceives of them, but such stereotypes also restrict Native Americans’
ability to believe in themselves and rise above the single story that others
have told for them.
While Native Americans may be prone to alcoholism, not
every Native American is an alcoholic. While some Native Americans are in the
casino business, many graduate high school and go on to attain degrees in
higher learning. Native Youth Magazine writes, “In response to the issues facing Native American
heritage, economic prosperity, and health, a number of government programs have
been put in place to level the playing field for people of native descent.
These range from grant programs for cultural programs to education trusts for
Native American students.” (Source: http://nativeyouthmagazine.com/pastpresentfuture.htm).
While it is true that the U.S. government devotes funding to Native Americans,
it would be absurd to believe that every Native American survives solely off of
government handouts.
Modern-day Native Americans are trying to do what the rest
of us are; they’re trying to find their place in the world. I believe that
Native Americans can overcome the single story told for them and aspire to the stories
of a noble, advanced, and spiritual people that were told to me of their predecessors
when I was a boy.
I can attest that this is a false portrayal of Native Americans. I know of many who said they didn't want to "sell their soul" to the reservation and left, no longer identifying as Native American to distance themselves from this single story. I know many others who are just assumed to be Mexican for their appearance. Really, the modern Native American is an average person who works hard and wants the same we all do for our families.
ReplyDeleteI have never even thought about this before. What a sad single story.
ReplyDelete