He is the father who gives the baby a chew toy and the dog a bottle because he can't take his eyes off the game. He is the husband who assures his wife he can handle an hour alone with the kids only to destroy the house in minutes. He can't be trusted to stay home with the baby. He can't change a diaper or cook lunch for the kids. He is just another kid for his wife to look after. He is a dumb dad.
The image of the "Bumbling Father" is very damaging. I remember sitting at the dinner table as a small child listening to my dad tell a story. I can't remember what he said but I do remember standing up, knocking on his head and saying "Anybody home??" I can't believe I did that! I respect my dad and I love him so much. What coerced me to even think such a thing was acceptable? Was it just an innate thing I knew? Did I learn it? Did it have anything to do with the back to back episodes of "The Simpsons" and "Malcolm in the Middle" I watched nearly every day after school?
Mass media is powerful. The things we watch and listen to have an effect on us. If every cleaning supply commercial shows a man assuring his wife over the phone that everything is fine while one kid is hanging from the banister and the other is dumping a gallon of milk on the floor, we might start to believe it. This is damaging to boys and men because they may see the images and think that's what's expected of them. They may also feel less confident in their abilities. Women may also start to think that theese images are what they can expect from men when it comes to fatherhood. This is a problem because women might be demeaning without reason. There are also negative effects on women. Everything is a complete disaster until mom gets home and she was only gone for an hour to buy groceries. In a time when women are fighting for equal rights in the workplace, they can't be shown as the only people capable of handling a home.
Men are capable beings! They can be wonderful, educated, responsible, engaged fathers, and they usually are! Commercials and sitcoms that show men as anything but capable fathers are damaging to men and women. If men are constantly told that they are bumbling and irresponsible, they may start to believe it and their wives, children and society may start to mindlessly treat them as such. If women are shown to be the only beings able to control children and maintain a home, their husbands, children and society may treat them as such. Although some men may in fact work while their wives stay home, neither men nor women need to be thought of in these incorrect ways.
I agree with you, Sydney! Men are capable beings. Media is definitely damaging us to view men with a single story.
ReplyDeleteI agree!
ReplyDeleteBut I would also be interested in seeing what time of day these specific shows air. I almost wonder if it's more common for them to air during the day when the "common housewife" has time to watch TV.
This is a great one! My mom always pointed that out to us growing up. We watched a lot of Disney shows and she always noted how the dads (like in Lizzie McGuire and That's So Raven) were always incredibly immature and less-than capable. I always just looked at them as funny characters--but I think there's a point to be made here.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI'm not going to lie, I'm a sucker for a funny, dumb dad character in TV and movies. But I understand the dangers that come with the constant stereotyping. When I'm a dad, I hope my kids perceive me as fun but a good role model at the same time.
ReplyDeleteI have seen a few campaigns recently about showing dad's as being important and good role models so hopefully this idea can change!
ReplyDeleteI have seen a few campaigns recently about showing dad's as being important and good role models so hopefully this idea can change!
ReplyDeleteI like your choice of topic to analyze. I agree with you about the strength of the media. It can influence us in our opinions and perceptions of individuals. I cannot even count the number of movies and TV shows that I have seen portrayals of father figures as clueless, happy go lucky guys and mother figures as organized, strict women. These types of portrayals are demeaning to the roles that both fathers and mothers hold.
ReplyDeleteThis is an awesome topic! Great analysis and evidence. I hadn't even thought about the "clueless father" until reading this, but it really is so true. Just about every TV show I watched as a kid portrayed the father like this. Probably not a great message to young kids. This could be the root of the problem.
ReplyDeleteThis is a very true single story that the media portrays right now.
ReplyDelete