I decided to examine homosexuality in the media. I thought it would be interesting to objectively approach such an emotionally-charged topic. In the following three examples, I noticed that homosexuality was not dealt with in a sensitive or inclusive manner.
In the film "I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry," two male friends participate in a fake homosexual marriage strictly for the financial perks. From the trailer alone, I could tell that the awkwardness of their forced relationship became a running joke throughout the film. To tell this kind of a story could be offensive to gay individuals, feeling as though their lifestyle had become the brunt of a feature-length Adam Sandler joke. To position homosexuality as nothing but a smart financial decision — and to then consistently make light of it — is insensitive. View the trailer here.
The 2004 film "Mean Girls" features a gay character named Damien. While I haven't seen the full film, I noticed from a compilation of clips that Damien appears to be on the fringes of the high school social scene. Positioning Damien as an "outcast" confirms and perpetuates the idea of excluding minority groups. While he seemed to be happy on the fringes, there was very little evidence that he was accepted or loved by the student body as a whole. View the Damien compilation here.
Lastly, a Giggo.com commercial unnecessarily — and perhaps unintentionally — implies that homosexuality merits rejection and negativity. View the commercial here.
In all three examples, the subject of homosexuality was not addressed with sensitivity. Rather, it was shown to be a source of humor, a cause of social division, and a reason for rejection. As a result, the media promotes a single, negative story about this lifestyle. The media fails to recognize the emotion, the tension, the struggle, the search for joy, and the people that are fundamental to the plot.
Good analysis. I also want to point out that Damien is portrayed in the film with pretty much every gay stereotype imaginable. To be fair this is a silly high school movie chop-full of stereotypes. But not only is the gay character unhappy and marginalized at school, he perpetuates a mold for homosexuals which, if they don't fit, can make it even more difficult to come out and to function in society as gay individuals.
ReplyDeleteI have seen Mean Girls and your assumptions were correct!
ReplyDeleteI like what you bring up about "I Now Pronaunce You..." By reinforcing fear or discomfort towards members of the LGBTQ community, we label them as "other", and labeling people as other never leads to food things.
ReplyDelete*good
DeleteIt seem like the caricatures in the materials referenced refer more to characters that are made up, rather than represent real people. You're right in saying this doesn't help represent the LGBTQ community fairly.
ReplyDelete